The reality dating franchise whose contestants the Readers’ Choice Poll honours in the Sexiest Love Island-er category, won in 2026 by Caleb McDaniel. The show’s villa romances produce instant, intense fan attachments, which is exactly the currency a fan vote trades in. McDaniel’s win places a reality newcomer on the same results page as film stars and footballers. The category has quickly become one of the poll’s most argued-about among younger voters online.
(Accedie / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0))
Mentioned in: Why 250,000 Votes Matter: The Readers’ Choice Poll Is Now the Real Sexiest Contest